Red Flags When Choosing a 3PL for Your CPG Brand (And How to Avoid Them)
You have a shortlist of 3PL providers. Now comes the part that determines whether your next partner helps you scale or quietly erodes your margins. Many emerging CPG brands sign with the first provider that sounds good on a call, only to face hidden fees, constant errors, or operations that never quite match their product needs. This page lists the red flags that show up during real evaluation; it explains why they hurt brands like yours and gives clear ways to spot them before you commit. The goal is simple: avoid the expensive headache of switching warehouses six months later.
Red Flags in First Conversations and Early Proposals
Serious 3PLs do not rush to pricing. They ask questions about your SKUs, temperature requirements, co-man setup, customer geography, and any unusual handling needs before they quote. They should always ask for rough estimates of pallets in and pallets out per month, expected pallet storage needs, and if you require case pick or each pick types of fulfillment. If a provider jumps straight to a price sheet without digging into your business, be hesitant; they are not giving you the time of day to even bother to understand your business. If they don’t assess your business as a fit for their business, you can’t expect them to be a good partner as you grow and resolve problems together.
Proposals with very short price lists are another warning. When the document covers only basic pallet in, pallet out, and monthly storage, everything else defaults to hourly labor. A single floor-loaded container, a potent-smelling batch, or a messy product can turn into thousands in unexpected charges. Good providers build custom per-pallet fees for recurring special needs; they understand your operation and price accordingly. This type of pricing understand is directly related to the first paragraph on taking the time to learn your business.
Slow replies during the sales process can often indicate slow support later. If it takes days to answer basic questions about facility certifications or client examples, expect the same delays when a co-man shipment arrives early or a retailer pushes back on labeling. Vague language around fees is common and costly. Terms like "estimated" or missing definitions for accessorials, peak multipliers, or how they handle odor containment or exceptions/incidents can lead to falling outs over costs later. Ask for exact definitions in writing, particularly during the phase as you negotiate a contract with the provider. If they hesitate, explain that you need things clearly defined so you can predict your costs and keep your business running smoothly and on budget.
Check out the FAQ below
Red Flags You See on Facility Tours and Follow Up Calls
Tour the warehouse yourself. There a few non-negotiable things I prefer to see when walking the floor of a food grade warehouse:
I always want to see the quarantine area. This is usually tucked away in a far back corner, and for good reason. Food items that get damaged or have other issues, but are still in disposition, end up here. They often stay here a long time. This is a great litmus test to see just how the warehouse handles the things they don’t want to deal with or won’t make money on. If this has dirty, sticky floors or pests; be very cautious.
The dock. The first place I visit during a walk through is a stroll down the entire dock. Look at the areas between roll-up doors for pallet debris. If you see a lot of wood fragments and debris from shrink wrap, chances are the warehouse is very relaxed on their cleaning protocols for new product coming in. When a truck is done, the staff should be cleaning up and removing this debris, not sweeping it between the doors to begin the next truck.
The floors. A warehouse with concrete floors is a constantly changing surface that is porous and can often trap dirt and moisture; this is not an issue. When you do a tour, you will often see areas where they just used a mopping/sweeping machine that are still drying; this is part of the routine day-to-day maintenance of a food handling facility. What I don’t like to see is areas with significant tire debris build up. You’ll notice high traffic areas have tire marks, but if you notice low traffic areas with old build up of tire marks, that might indicate the daily cleaning is neglected. I also look to see if my tour guide picks up debris as we walk, or if there is debris in the unused pallet spaces in the racking.
If a warehouse passes these 3 visual observations, even without actual SQF/BRCGS/GFSI certifications, they can certainly meet all requirements to operate as a USDA controlled facility.
Ask about staffing difficulty during the visit. High turnover among pickers and receivers means inconsistent handling and more touches per order; that drives up your effective cost even if base rates look attractive. People rarely admit to high turnover, but if they do mention having a good placement company that they rely on, then it’s a good indication that they use standardized instructions (SOPs) and expectations for new hires, and you shouldn’t notice a huge difference for every new person handling your product.
If you have requirements like API/EDI or order management, be sure to ask if they currently run that setup with other customers. It is often very tough sledding when you are the first to forge a new workflow with your provider.
Contract Essentials: Negotiate Terms That Protect Your CPG Brand
You have vetted providers through conversations, proposals, and facility tours. The contract is where everything solidifies and this vendor becomes a long-term partner. Emerging CPG brands often sign standard templates without reviewing and revising for their needs; they end up locked into rigid terms, surprise fees, or weak recourse when performance slips. Negotiate deliberately. Focus on clarity, accountability, and flexibility that match your growth stage and product realities. This is not a personal argument, we are asking for changes to a contract because our business needs are uniquely our own.
Define Service Level Agreements (SLAs) with Real Teeth
SLAs set the baseline for performance. These usually include a defined metric, a time period for measurement, a penalty for failure to achieve (often not on the first failure), and a mechanism to deduct the penalty from invoices. More details on each of these segments.
Define a metric, pick numbers that actually matter to your brand. For example: Order accuracy: 99.0 percent or higher (measured as percentage of orders shipped without errors in quantity, SKU, labeling, or packaging). Another example can be lot code picking, which is very common in food handling warehouses. Lot code accuracy greater than 99.5 percent, measured as percentage of orders shipped without the lot code specified in the customer order.
Set the measurement period, most contracts measure monthly. Some high-volume brands negotiate weekly reporting for early detection. Require the 3PL to provide a monthly SLA report by the 10th of the following month, showing actual performance against each target, with root-cause analysis for any misses.
Build in penalties that sting but stay reasonable. Penalties usually kick in after a grace period or threshold to account for rare anomalies. Examples from actual 3PL agreements:
Order accuracy below 99.0 percent: credit of 5 percent of the monthly invoiced amount for the affected service line (pick/pack fees), capped at 15 percent per month.
On-time shipping below 98.5 percent: credit of $0.25 per affected order, or 3 percent of outbound fees for the month.
Inventory accuracy below 99.5 percent: credit of 10 percent of storage fees plus reimbursement of any documented retailer chargebacks directly caused by the discrepancy.
Temperature excursion: full reimbursement of product value for spoiled inventory plus $500 per incident as liquidated damages.
Repeated breaches (e.g., three consecutive months below target): escalation to senior management review and option to terminate without penalty after 30-day cure period.
Enforcement mechanisms. Automatic credits. Require the contract to state that qualifying SLA credits are applied to the next invoice without needing separate approval. Nothing is more painful than a contract with teeth, that ends up costing a brand a lot of money, because they need to invoice the warehouse and then wait for them to pay that invoice.
Escalation path. Define steps: first miss triggers written explanation and corrective action plan within 5 business days; second miss in a quarter triggers joint review call; third triggers right to terminate.
Audit rights. Allow you (or a third-party auditor) to verify performance data upon reasonable notice.
Dispute resolution. Include a 30-day window to challenge reported metrics, with independent arbitration if no resolution.
It is important to remember that this contract language is not designed to generate revenue or extract pain from either party. It is designed to set a monetary reimbursement related to the costs that you will incur from failures. Good partners look to exercise these contract clauses rarely, as the issues are caught early enough to be resolved.
Require Pre-Approval for Hourly and Non-Standard Labor
Hourly charges for exceptions can explode costs. State in the contract that all non-standard work needs a written quote and your explicit approval first. Good providers accept this; they often provide the quote proactively when an issue arises. This protects against surprises like floor-loaded containers, repalletizing, or special handling for potent-smelling batches. If recurring needs exist, negotiate custom per-pallet fees upfront. A fixed rate for known quirks keeps budgeting predictable.
Build in Pricing Transparency and Controls
Demand itemized breakdowns for every fee category: receiving, storage (pallet or cubic), pick/pack (case vs. each), accessorials, and surcharges. Eliminate "estimated" language; require exact definitions. Cap rate increases. Allow adjustments only at renewal or with mutual agreement, tied to documented cost changes like labor or fuel. Include a review clause every 12 months to adjust based on actual volume and performance.
Address hidden fees head-on. Long-term storage penalties for slow-moving SKUs, peak season multipliers, or material markups should be spelled out or capped. If your product has quirks like mess potential or odor, negotiate buffer zones or dedicated handling without open-ended hourly rates.
Network and Product-Specific Protections
Include clauses on co-man handoffs and geography. Require efficient inbound processes from your suppliers and outbound alignment with customer concentrations to minimize freight. For food CPG, reference compliance standards. Require FSMA/FDA registration, SQF/BRCGS if applicable, and allergen controls. Add audit rights and notification for any regulatory issues.
Exit Strategy: Make It Feasible
Warehouse switches cost time, money, and retailer trust. It is recommended to try and pick the best partner first, but if you are already in a warehouse provider to do everything you can to salvage the relationship and build it as a partnership. Negotiate reasonable termination: 60-90 day notice, no punitive fees for performance-based exits, free data export, and assistance with inventory transfer coordination.
Include trial provisions. Start with a limited volume or shorter initial term to test real operations before full commitment.
Negotiating the contract tests the partnership. A provider that collaborates on fair, clear terms shows they value long-term fit. Push for what protects your margins and growth; the result is a relationship built on accountability, not surprises.
Choosing a 3PL is one of the biggest operational decisions an emerging or mid-market CPG brand makes. The wrong partner leads to hidden fees, order errors, chargebacks, and constant firefighting that kills margins and retailer trust. The right one aligns with your co-man, product quirks, and customer geography while delivering predictable costs and reliable execution. Approach the process methodically; the cost of switching warehouses later is far higher than the time spent vetting upfront.
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the biggest red flags during initial sales conversations with a 3PL?
The provider jumps straight to pricing without asking detailed questions about your SKUs, temperature needs, co-man handoffs, customer geography, or special handling requirements. Serious 3PLs qualify you as much as you qualify them; they want to understand your business before quoting. If they skip this step, they are likely treating you as a generic account, which predicts poor long-term fit and support.
Why are short price lists such a problem for CPG brands?
A very short list that only covers basic pallet in/out and storage means almost everything else defaults to hourly labor. One floor-loaded container, a potent-smelling batch, or a messy product can rack up thousands in surprise charges. Better providers build custom per-pallet fees for recurring special needs after they learn your operation; this keeps costs predictable.
What should I look for during a warehouse tour?
Focus on three visual checks in a food-grade facility: the quarantine area (should be clean and organized, not neglected); the dock (minimal debris between doors after truck unloading); and the floors (routine mopping is normal, but old tire-mark buildup in low-traffic areas signals poor daily cleaning). These quick observations reveal how seriously the warehouse handles maintenance and non-revenue tasks.
How do I make SLAs enforceable in a 3PL contract?
Define clear metrics (order accuracy 99 percent, on-time shipping 98.5 percent, inventory accuracy 99.5 percent), measure monthly, and build in automatic credits (e.g., 5 percent of monthly fees for accuracy misses) or liquidated damages (e.g., $500 per temperature excursion). Require the 3PL to send performance reports by the 10th of each month, with root-cause analysis for failures. Add escalation: first miss gets a corrective plan within five days; repeated breaches trigger termination rights after a cure period.